The hardest part of telling a scam from a real business is that the real ones got weird. Modern commerce will fund, ship, and profitably operate ideas that sound like a punchline. Here are real businesses that pass the "wait, that can't be real" test — and prove that ridiculous has never meant illegal.
1. Rent-a-goat landscaping
Several companies will deliver a herd of goats to eat the weeds and brush off your land, then take them home. It's real, it's eco-friendly, it's often cheaper than machinery on steep terrain, and yes, there can be surge demand. The goats are the product, the labor, and the marketing all at once.
2. Liquid Death — canned water that became a $1.4B brand
It's water. In a tallboy can. With a heavy-metal skull and the slogan "Murder Your Thirst." By leaning entirely into branding for a commodity anyone can get from a tap, Liquid Death built a cult following and a valuation reported around $1.4 billion. The product is mundane; the marketing is the moat.
3. The $6.2 million banana
Artist Maurizio Cattelan's "Comedian" is a banana duct-taped to a wall. It first sold at Art Basel in 2019 for around $120,000–$150,000. In 2024, an edition sold at auction for $6.2 million. You're not buying the banana (you replace it); you're buying a certificate and the concept. Stupid? Maybe. Fake? Absolutely not.
4. The Pet Rock
In 1975, Gary Dahl sold ordinary rocks in a box with air holes and a tongue-in-cheek "care manual." He reportedly sold over a million in months and became a millionaire. The product did nothing. The joke — and the packaging — did everything.
5. "I Am Rich" — the $999.99 app that did nothing
In 2008 an app called I Am Rich sold for the App Store's maximum price, $999.99, and its only function was to display a glowing red gem to prove you could waste $1,000. A handful of people actually bought it before Apple pulled it. Pure, legal, status-signaling absurdity.
6. Canned fresh air
Companies have bottled "fresh mountain air" and sold it — notably to buyers in heavily polluted cities. It's exactly what it sounds like: cans of air, sold at a premium, entirely legally. The customer base is real even when the product is comedic.
7. Professional cuddling
Licensed-ish "cuddle therapists" and cuddling studios charge by the hour for platonic, non-romantic touch. It's a real service with real demand, real liability waivers, and real Yelp reviews. Strange to some; a legitimate wellness business nonetheless.
8. Cards Against Humanity dug a giant hole
On Black Friday 2016, the card-game company ran a "Holiday Hole" promotion: a live stream of an excavator digging a pointless hole, with a button asking people to donate money to keep it digging. People gave roughly $100,000 to fund nothing. The stunt was real, the money was real, the hole was very real.
"This sounds ridiculous" is not evidence of fraud. A real business just needs a real product (even a dumb one), a real customer (even a baffling one), and the law on its side. Plenty of legitimate companies are overpriced, pointless, or spiritually bankrupt — and still completely legal.
So how do you tell these from scams?
The absurd-but-real ones deliver something: a goat shows up, a can of water arrives, a certificate of a banana changes hands. A scam, by contrast, mostly sells the opportunity to make money — the course about the course, the guaranteed yield, the system whose only output is more systems. When the only product is the promise, that's your tell. We break down the full checklist in how to spot a scam.
Examples summarized from widely reported public records; valuations and prices are approximate and as reported at the time.
Sources & further reading
Related
- ▶ Play Scam or Real Business? — can you tell these from the fakes?
- 📖 How to spot a scam
- 📖 Famous startup scams & flops
- 📚 More explainers in the Learn hub